DOL Proposes Major Changes to the PERM Labor Certification Process

The Department of Labor (DOL) has issued a proposed rule that would substantially change the PERM labor certification process. If finalized as proposed, the rule would modernize and expand PERM recruitment requirements, impose new restrictions relating to layoffs, eliminate Schedule A exemptions, and establish new documentation requirements and stricter compliance obligations for employers.

DOL will accept comments on the proposed rule for 60 days. The proposed changes will not take effect unless and until DOL issues a final rule, a process that typically takes several months and may take considerably longer. DOL is also proposing a 90-day transition framework following publication of a final rule: a 60-day delayed effective date followed by an additional 30-day transition period. If implemented, the final rule could also face legal challenges.

Here is a summary of some of the major changes DOL is proposing:

1. PERM recruitment

DOL proposes replacing the current requirement of two Sunday newspaper advertisements and additional recruitment steps for professional positions with the following mandatory recruitment methods:

  • a State Workforce Agency job order, which is already required;

  • posting on the employer’s business website, on the same page where the employer customarily posts non-PERM job opportunities;

  • advertising on at least one independent job-search website, with required posting on all such websites customarily used by the employer for comparable positions;

  • social media advertising when the employer ordinarily uses social media to recruit for similar positions; and

  • at least one job fair, on-campus recruiting event, or recruitment effort through a college, university, or trade-school placement office.

Employers would also be required to conduct PERM recruitment using the same methods they ordinarily use to recruit for comparable non-PERM positions. Advertisement content requirements would become more detailed, including a requirement to disclose the offered wage or wage range. Most recruitment would need to remain active for at least 90 calendar days. Applicants for PERM positions would need to be directed to apply through the employer’s usual recruitment channels rather than through a PERM-specific method.

The internal Notice of Filing would no longer need to be physically posted at the worksite if it is posted electronically. However, the Notice of Filing would need to be posted before the PERM application is filed and remain posted for a significantly longer period, generally until the related I-140 petition is approved.

2. Review of the employer’s recruitment for substantially comparable occupations

DOL proposes comparing the PERM position’s minimum requirements with the requirements used in the employer’s recruitment for the same or substantially comparable occupations during the preceding 12 months. If the PERM position has materially more stringent requirements, the employer could be required to establish business necessity for each material difference. As a result, consistency between the requirements for a PERM position and the employer’s ordinary recruiting history would become much more important. This could create problems for employers that typically recruit listing very broad and/or non-specific requirements rather than the detailed, more specific requirements necessitated by the PERM process.

3. New layoff restrictions

An employer generally would be prohibited from filing a PERM application if it had laid off a U.S. worker in the same or a similar occupation in the relevant geographic area during the preceding two years. This would be substantially broader than the current six-month layoff review period. Further, unlike the current process, the filing could not occur even if the employer notifies and considers relevant laid off U.S. workers. For employers that place workers at third-party client sites, where there are indicia of an employment relationship between the employee and the client, a PERM cannot be filed if the client laid off workers in that occupation within the same two-year period.

After the PERM application is filed, relevant layoffs would continue to create obligations through adjudication of the related I-140 petition. Employers could be required to notify DOL and USCIS of relevant layoffs and consider potentially qualified laid-off U.S. workers for the PERM position.

4. Documentation requirements

Instead of retaining recruitment documentation for submission only in the event of an audit, employers would be required to submit substantial recruitment documentation with every PERM application, including:

  • the recruitment report;

  • evidence of the recruitment steps;

  • the Notice of Filing;

  • applicants’ resumes and applications; and

  • documentation concerning the disposition of U.S. applicants.

5. Elimination of Schedule A

Employers sponsoring professional nurses, physical therapists, and individuals presently covered by Schedule A, Group II would no longer be able to bypass the standard PERM process. These employers generally would need to obtain a prevailing wage determination, conduct the required labor-market test, and receive DOL labor certification before filing the I-140 petition.

6. Increased compliance and enforcement

The proposal includes expanded employer attestations, broader audit and supervised-recruitment authority, potential referrals to DOJ, EEOC, DHS, and other agencies, and expanded debarment standards. Debarment under the PERM program could also extend to DOL’s Labor Condition Application program for H-1B workers.

Employers would therefore need to treat PERM recruitment as an extension of their ordinary HR and recruiting processes rather than as a separate immigration exercise.

Key takeaways

Because this is only a proposed rule, no immediate changes to existing PERM practices are required. However, when beginning a new PERM case, employers should consider the following:

  • Layoff history: Identify whether anticipated PERM positions overlap with occupations affected by layoffs during the preceding two years.

  • Timing strategies: For appropriate cases, consider whether to begin the labor-market test before issuance of the prevailing wage determination to facilitate filing the PERM application before any final rule takes effect. Recruitment completed before the prevailing wage determination is issued should be carefully timed to ensure that it remains valid when the PERM application is filed.

  • Job-requirement consistency: Review job postings for the same or substantially comparable positions during the preceding 12 months to evaluate consistency with the requirements contemplated for the PERM position. Where requirements differ materially, determine whether they should be revised or supported by a business-necessity justification.

Next
Next

New Immigration Rule Ends “D/S” for F and J Nonimmigrants